Halloween Mystery Box

Want a more personalized scare?
👉 Note your favorite teams at checkout and we’ll do our best to tailor your mystery box for a more selective surprise.

Think you’re getting tricked? Think again.

Our entry-level Halloween Mystery Box comes packed with spooky surprises — autographed memorabilia valued at no less than $150! Each box includes a guaranteed signed item from one of baseball or football’s fan-favorite stars. Perfect for collectors who love a good surprise (without the frightful price tag).

The Treat Box is where things get even sweeter — a collector’s dream filled with premium autographed items valued at over $350! From rising stars to household names, this box brings high-end Halloween energy to your collection. Every box is a treat — no tricks here.

The Ultimate Haunt Box is the crown jewel of Halloween collecting — an elite mystery experience packed with autographed memorabilia valued $1,100+. Expect star power, rare pieces, and spooky-good surprises that will leave any fan haunted by how good the value is.